Sustainability benchmarking in private equity: building a peer group when disclosure is thin

By Neural Alpha · Updated · 6 min read

The short answer

A sustainability benchmark shows a private equity team where a portfolio company sits against its peers and which gaps belong in the value creation plan. In private markets it is harder to build than for listed companies, because portfolio companies disclose far less, so the choice of peer group matters: disclosed peers give a reference point when the company’s own reporting is thin. Most of the time goes into collecting comparable data across the group, which is the step AI can take over.

  • A benchmark turns a company’s sustainability position into gaps and priorities for the value creation plan.
  • Private companies disclose less, so disclosed peers provide the reference point.
  • Choose the peer group and the questions first; the data collection follows from them.
  • Repeat the same benchmark through the hold to show how far the gap has closed.

6–7%

estimated multiple uplift at exit from sustainability efforts, the upside a benchmark helps locate

Source: PRI with Bain & Company

9

EDCI metric categories for the 2027 reporting cycle, a common quantitative core for private company benchmarks

Source: ESG Data Convergence Initiative

Why benchmark sustainability in private equity?

For a private equity team, a benchmark is what shows where a portfolio company sits against its peers, and what belongs in the value creation plan. The PRI’s Sustainability Value Creation framework puts it at due diligence: compare the target’s sustainability performance with peers and industry benchmarks to find the largest gaps, which are the upside, and the material themes.

The benchmark keeps its value after the deal. Repeated through the hold, it shows how far the company has closed the gap, which is the evidence an exit story needs.

Why is benchmarking harder in private markets?

Listed companies publish sustainability reports, respond to questionnaires and are covered by ratings. Most private companies do none of these, and what they do publish varies in scope and format. A benchmark built only on the portfolio company’s own disclosure has little to compare.

That is why the peer group matters. The disclosed peers, listed or private, are what give you a reference point when the company’s own reporting is thin: what similar businesses report on climate targets, water use or human rights shows what good looks like in that sector, and where the company is likely to stand.

How do you build a sustainability benchmark?

  1. Choose the peer group

    Direct competitors, companies with the same business model and similar size, and aspirational peers that lead the sector. Include disclosed peers so the group has data to compare against.

  2. Choose the questions

    Start from the material topics for the sector and the fund’s own priorities: climate targets, water management, human rights policies, health and safety, or your own criteria.

  3. Collect the evidence for every company

    Find and read each company’s reports, policies and website, and answer the same questions for every company in the same way.

  4. Compare and prioritise

    Show where the portfolio company leads and lags, and which gaps are worth closing in the value creation plan.

  5. Repeat through the hold

    Re-run the same benchmark each year against the same peers and questions, so progress can be shown at exit.

What to benchmark

Materiality decides the topics. For the quantitative core, the EDCI metrics are the natural starting point in private equity: LPs already ask for them, so portfolio companies are more likely to have the figures, and they are defined the same way for every company. A starting point for most portfolios:

TopicQuestions to ask across the peer group
ClimateIs there a target, is it science-based, what are scope 1 and 2 emissions and their intensity?
WaterIs water use measured, is there a management policy, are sites in water-stressed areas?
Human rightsIs there a human rights policy and supply chain due diligence, have there been controversies?
Health and safetyAre injury rates disclosed, how do they compare with the sector?
GovernanceBoard independence, anti-bribery controls, sustainability oversight at board level
Your own criteriaAny question the fund asks of its portfolio, answered the same way for every peer

Where the time goes, and how AI helps

Building a sustainability benchmark takes time, and most of it goes into collecting comparable data across the peer group. The analysis is the short part.

For examples of how clients benchmark with Neural Alpha, see our case studies.

Frequently asked questions

What is a sustainability benchmark?

A comparison of a company’s sustainability performance, policies and disclosures with a defined peer group, answering the same questions for every company so the gaps and leads are visible.

Why do private equity firms benchmark portfolio companies?

To find where a company trails its peers, which shows the upside and what belongs in the value creation plan, and to show at exit how far the company has closed that gap.

How do you benchmark a private company that discloses little?

Build the peer group around companies that do disclose, listed or private, so they provide the reference point, and combine the company’s own documents with what the fund collects in due diligence.

How do you choose a peer group for a sustainability benchmark?

Combine direct competitors, companies with the same business model and similar size, and aspirational sector leaders, making sure enough of them disclose on the topics you want to compare.

What is the difference between a sustainability benchmark and an ESG rating?

An ESG rating is a provider’s score on its own methodology, and most private companies have none. A benchmark is your comparison: you choose the peers and the questions, and every answer is traceable to the company’s documents.

How often should a portfolio company be benchmarked?

At due diligence to set the baseline, then once a year through the hold against the same peers and questions, so progress is comparable and can be shown at exit.

What topics should a private equity sustainability benchmark cover?

The topics that are material for the sector, typically climate, water, human rights, health and safety and governance, plus any criteria the fund applies across its portfolio.

Just CapitalBGFThe Baltic ExchangeWWFAquila CapitalStandard LifeTNFDStockholm Environment Institute

Less noise. More materiality.

Bring a company, portfolio or research topic, and see in minutes what moves value and drives impact.